Bridgewaters NYC: Seaport event venue and Twenty Four Fifth

Bridgewaters NYC: Seaport event venue and Twenty Four Fifth

In short: Bridgewaters was the Glazier Group’s large event venue at 11 Fulton Street in the South Street Seaport, with harbor and Brooklyn Bridge views. Twenty Four Fifth was its ballroom in the former Fifth Avenue Hotel. Both held weddings and corporate events until 2012, when Hurricane Sandy flooded the Seaport and the Glaziers left Twenty Four Fifth.

Many New Yorkers who never ate at a Glazier restaurant went to a wedding, a gala or an office party at Bridgewaters NYC. The venue, and its sister ballroom on lower Fifth Avenue, were the events side of the business described on the old company website. This guide covers both rooms, what they offered, and what happened to them. Manhattan Tables is independent and does not book events.

What was Bridgewaters?

Bridgewaters was a private event venue on the upper floor of the Fulton Market Building at 11 Fulton Street. A private event venue is a space that hosts booked functions rather than walk-in diners. In its 2008 wedding guide New York magazine described two lofty rooms for 75 to 400 guests, views of the Brooklyn Bridge and the harbor, and wraparound terraces. Menus started at $195 a person, and outside caterers were not allowed except for kosher events.

The archived Glazier Group website listed Bridgewaters with Strip House, Michael Jordan’s and Twenty Four Fifth, and said its catering arm, Bridgewaters On Location, served events across the tri-state area.

Tall loft windows framing a suspension bridge over a river at sunset with set tables inside
Bridgewaters looked out on the Brooklyn Bridge and the harbor. Illustration.

The South Street Seaport setting

The Seaport is the historic port district on the East River in Lower Manhattan. Wikipedia’s South Street Seaport entry describes its restored 19th-century buildings and the redevelopments of the area. Bridgewaters’ landlord was a subsidiary of the Howard Hughes Corporation, according to The Real Deal, which put the venue at 28,000 square feet. BizBash gave 27,000 square feet, so the published size varies slightly.

An empty wraparound terrace with railings overlooking a harbor in the evening
Wraparound terraces were part of the appeal. Illustration.

Twenty Four Fifth, the ballroom near Washington Square

Twenty Four Fifth was a smaller, more formal room. New York magazine’s 2007 wedding listings placed it in the former Fifth Avenue Hotel, with Rockwell-designed topiaries, a sunken marble dance floor, room for 200 at dinner or 400 for cocktails, and prices from $165 a person. The Knot lists the building, dating from 1926, among historic New York wedding venues.

In an interview with BizBash, Penny Glazier described the planned 8,400-square-foot space in the hotel’s former ballroom. Court papers in 24 Fifth Owners v. Glazier record a lease that began on 1 January 2002.

The two venues compared

FeatureBridgewatersTwenty Four Fifth
Address11 Fulton Street, South Street Seaport24 Fifth Avenue, Greenwich Village
BuildingFulton Market BuildingFormer Fifth Avenue Hotel
Capacity75 to 400 guests200 seated, 400 cocktails
Price listedFrom $195 a person (2008)From $165 a person (2007)
SignatureBridge and harbor views, terracesSunken marble dance floor
EndClosed by Hurricane Sandy, October 2012Tenant vacated, November 2012
A sunken marble dance floor in a classical ballroom ringed by topiary trees
Twenty Four Fifth had a sunken marble dance floor. Illustration.

Hurricane Sandy and the Seaport closure

Hurricane Sandy hit New York on 29 October 2012 and flooded much of the Seaport. The South Street Seaport Museum has documented the damage to the district. Eater noted two days later, in a round-up of Seaport restaurants, that Bridgewaters occupied a second floor.

The building was still shut. The Real Deal reported that Bridgewaters sued the landlord on 24 December 2012, saying the building had been yellow-tagged, that more than 50 events had been cancelled and that it had lost $1.7 million. A later insurance case, Glazier v. Nova, describes three to four inches of water on the first floor, watermarks five to six feet up the walls and flooded elevator pits.

What the lawsuit claimed

The two sides told very different stories. According to The Real Deal, Bridgewaters said it had suffered only minor wind damage and had planned to reopen in November, while the landlord said the space was unfit for use because of damage to the building’s elevators, gas lines and sprinkler systems. A landlord letter of 14 November said the venue could not reopen. Bridgewaters said it was still paying employees about $20,000 a week, and that a 14 December letter threatened to hold it in default over two months of unpaid rent, about $347,000.

The suit also claimed that the landlord wanted the venue out because its lease, which ran to December 2016, was below market rate and because the landlord ran a competing catering business. The Seaport’s Pier 17 mall reopened on 16 December. The suit asked for a restraining order to block eviction and force repairs, with a hearing set for January 2013. In early November, BizBash had reported that Bridgewaters was still without power, one of several downtown venues and hotels closed after the storm.

A water line stain on a white interior wall above a damp wooden floor
Sandy left watermarks on the Seaport buildings. Illustration.

The end of Twenty Four Fifth

Twenty Four Fifth closed in the same weeks. The court decision says Peter Glazier wrote on 13 November 2012 that the tenant had vacated, and that the landlord won a judgment of $477,009.07 on 22 February 2013. With the two halls gone, the Glazier Group’s events business, described in our company history, came to an end in Manhattan.

Key takeaways

  • Bridgewaters NYC was the Glazier Group’s 27,000 to 28,000 square foot venue at 11 Fulton Street.
  • It held 75 to 400 guests, with Brooklyn Bridge views and terraces.
  • Twenty Four Fifth was a ballroom in the former Fifth Avenue Hotel with a sunken marble dance floor.
  • Hurricane Sandy closed Bridgewaters in October 2012, with more than 50 events cancelled.
  • The Glaziers left Twenty Four Fifth in November 2012.

Common questions

Is Bridgewaters still open?

Not as the Glazier Group venue. It closed after Hurricane Sandy in October 2012, and its operator sued the landlord over reopening in December 2012. The Seaport has been redeveloped since, so check current listings for event spaces in the area.

How many guests did Bridgewaters hold?

New York magazine’s 2008 wedding guide described two rooms for 75 to 400 guests, with menus from $195 a person and in-house catering only, except for kosher events. Published sizes for the space range from 27,000 to 28,000 square feet.

What was Twenty Four Fifth?

A ballroom event venue at 24 Fifth Avenue, in the former Fifth Avenue Hotel. It had a sunken marble dance floor and Rockwell-designed topiaries, and held 200 for dinner or 400 for cocktails, according to New York magazine in 2007.

Why did Bridgewaters sue its landlord?

Bridgewaters filed a breach of contract suit on 24 December 2012, saying the landlord, a Howard Hughes Corporation subsidiary, was blocking it from reopening after Sandy and trying to evict it. The landlord cited damage to elevators, gas lines and sprinklers. The Real Deal reported both sides’ claims.

Were these restaurants or event spaces?

Both were event spaces for booked functions such as weddings and corporate parties, not restaurants open to walk-in diners. The Glazier restaurants are covered in our guides to Strip House and Monkey Bar.

How we put this together: capacities and prices come from New York magazine’s wedding listings; the Sandy story from The Real Deal, Eater, BizBash, the Seaport Museum and a 2018 court decision; the Twenty Four Fifth lease from a court judgment. Prices are as published at the time and are not current.

Sources

Back to the Manhattan Tables home page.